12 favorites     20 comments    445 visits

1/80 f/9.0 37.1 mm ISO 160

SONY DSC-RX100M2

EXIF - See more details

See also...

Everyone's Photo Pool Everyone's Photo Pool


Tolerance Tolerance


Flickr Refugees Flickr Refugees


Scaffolding Scaffolding


Downtown Toronto Downtown Toronto


Toronto Toronto


See more...

Keywords

canada
toronto
ontario
royal ontario museum
michael lee chin crystal


Authorizations, license

Visible by: Everyone
All rights reserved

445 visits


The Crystal

The Crystal
Renovation of the Michael Lee-Chin Crystal, an extension of the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto (2007, Daniel Libeskind). It's called the Crystal because it's spiky. Here's a view of its spikiness:
1.bp.blogspot.com/-0b-qIauvHHw/VR9FGbIX1tI/AAAAAAAAMOM/l7KUswx8rec/s1600/ROM%2BCristal%2BMichael%2BLee-Chin%2BCrystal1.JPG

Widely reviled by Torontonians, it nevertheless appeals to tourists. Tourism is a big industry here, so it's got that going for it.

Despite my general admiration of Libeskind's work, I think he missed the target here. In particular, even the building's admirers admit it is impractical as part of a museum.

The Washington Post chose this building as the worst of its decade. On the other hand, it has its supporters. Christopher Hume of the Toronto Star, for example contended that it "seemed to express a desire to bring not just the museum, not just the corner of Bloor and Avenue Road, but the whole city, into the 21st century without diminishing the past". Which is as may be, but it seems to me that whether it has achieved that desire is still an open question (to be fair, Hume seems to think so, too).

I think it looks better with the scaffolding (seriously, the rectangles create tension with the less regular geometry of the building). Maybe the ROM could be persuaded to leave it up.

Phil Sutters, tiabunna, Malik Raoulda, kiiti and 8 other people have particularly liked this photo


20 comments - The latest ones
 Sarah P.
Sarah P.
I like the scaffolding too. Actually reminds me of a crystalline structure.
5 years ago.
Sarah P. has added
At least you don't have a grotesque tower of babel sticking out of the middle of your skyline.
brokeassstuart.com/sf/2017/10/18/the-salesforce-tower-looks-like-a-giant-butt-plug
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Sarah P.
The Gherkin in London has always reminded me of a suppository.
5 years ago.
Sarah P. has replied to John FitzGerald club
Perhaps best not to go to far into that deep end ...
I see you used your (older?) camera for this shot. How are you liking your new one? (The SONY ILCE-6000?)
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Sarah P.
It's aka the α-6000 or A6000 mirrorless, Sarah. I like it -- quality pixels that you can edit aggressively in JPEG with fewer artefacts like halos; sharp, large photos that can be heavily cropped; and -- something which is very important up here -- it performs well in the cold (as does my ancient Sony RX100 Mk 2). The big drawback of the camera for me is lack of IS for raw files. I'm working on that problem, though.

I used the RX100for this one because I had things to do yesterday at which carrying around a bigger camera would have been inconvenient.
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has added
I should have mentioned that the A6000 is slow to start.
5 years ago.
 rdhinmn
rdhinmn club
Or a spider web. It certainly is intricate. I'd never find my way out of the maze.
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to rdhinmn club
Amazing stuff, scaffolding. Wouldn't want to be working on it in the typical Great Lakes wind, though.
5 years ago. Edited 5 years ago.
 Ulrich John
Ulrich John club
Very well seen, John ! A very interesting view !
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Ulrich John club
Thanks, Ulrich.
5 years ago.
 Keith Burton
Keith Burton club
I've just googled some pics of the museum...............and I have to say I think it's an eyesore! There seems to been no effort at all to make it fit with the surroundings..!!

I can see why the locals aren't keen on it and I think you're right about the scaffolding being an improvement!

A cracking image John!
5 years ago. Edited 5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Keith Burton club
Thanks, Keith. Unfortunately this is far from the biggest architectural eyesore in Toronto. I consider this one more of an eyesore, but even it is not the biggest eyesore:
Sharp Centre for Design
5 years ago.
Keith Burton club has replied to John FitzGerald club
Oooh yes, I remember that one. You ought to do a project on "Eyesores in Toronto" John.
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to Keith Burton club
That's a good idea, Keith. Lots of scope there. Thanks.
5 years ago.
 William Sutherland
William Sutherland club
Excellent shot!

Admired in:
www.ipernity.com/group/tolerance
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to William Sutherland club
Thanks, William.
5 years ago.
 tiabunna
tiabunna club
Thanks for flagging this to me, John. Yes, modern architecture can be very much a 'love it/hate it' exercise. I found a (seemingly inert) scaffolding group where this image would certainly fit.
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to tiabunna club
Bealted thanks, Keith. I have submitted the photo to the group you recommended. I'll probably join, too. Scaffolding everywhere here.

An interesting set of modern buildings here is Brookfield Place. Two towers that are not the best work their architects have ever done, connected by a brilliant atrium by Santiago Calatrava.
5 years ago.
 bertapei
bertapei
beautiful !
5 years ago.
John FitzGerald club has replied to bertapei
Thanks, berta.
5 years ago.

Sign-in to write a comment.