Group: i-Central


Critique on TPAM


Arne
By A Arne
29 Sep 2007 - 3 comments - 432 visits- Permalink   |   Translate title into English

THis thread is meant for us to help each other taking better pictures.
The idea is you look for a foto in the stream of the person above you. Then you criticise on one point. This means you look for one thing in the foto that you think could be done better. Then you post this foto in medium size and tell your critique which includes telling how you think this could have been done better.

In short:
- pick foto of TPAMs stream
- find one criticism
- tell how you think it could be done better

And remember the next time you will be in the focus of the critique. ;)
So remember: keep being friendly and constructive we can all profi from this!

I think that this will certainly call for more discussions on the topics.

These discussions can take place in a seperate discussion-thread.

The topic of this discussion has been edited by Arne 7 years ago.

Comments
 Roberto Ballerini - traveling
Roberto Ballerini -…
I'm here to learn and critique and opinions are a great instrument for this, IMHO.
So, let's start; tell me what do you think about this shot:
"Old basket" by Roberto Ballerini <away> [?]
Old basket by Roberto Ballerini <away>
17 years ago.
Arne has replied to Roberto Ballerini -…
Ok, I'll gladly do so. although the idea was to start by critisizing a foto of the person above. :)

Anyway. To tell in advance I like the picture.

Now one criticism: It is hard to tell the basket from the trees. Since this is black&white you could have tried to seperate the basket from the trees either by lighting or by chosing a larger DOF so that the ring of the basket is still sharp and the trees are not. I think the sharpness method would destroy the picture too much. So I would try to go with a little different lightint. Just my opinion. :)

Now. Somebody choose one of my pictures and criticise it.

For further discussions of this foto please use the discussion thread.
17 years ago.
Roberto Ballerini -… has replied to Arne
Sorry, Arne, for the misunderstanding.
17 years ago.

You must be a member of this group to reply to this topic. (Join?)